Sure is. Especially live! Having Yuriko do her high harmony on stage! Joelle does an good job singing Wakana's parts, even though she has a totally different resonance and tone. Quattro's strings raises the level of the song above the original studio version.
@@ryoukoizumi I completely 100% agree with you. Yuki Kajiura wrote for FJ and Kalafina to have 4 voices. That's why I suspect that Maya's leaving was against Kajiura's wishes.
Oh performing this right at the beginning of the concert was crazy I was not ready... I'm joking of course but I was surprised to hear it so soon!! Absolutely fabulous!!!
I really hope that the next madoka movie has ficionjunction for the theme song 🥲we can have a song led by keiko and maybe they can bring hikaru since she is still working with kajiura
Joelle is good please dont compare her to wakana...we all know wakana voice is really rare because of it husky thats why they always fit.together with keiko..
@@hungryghost96 I can understand being used to a singer (in this case Wakana), but if we follow that logic then we could also say anytime FictionJunction or Kalafina covers a song by FJ Yuuka, See-Saw, or even Emily Bindiger and others it sounds "wrong". We should be able to extend our appreciation beyond a particular singer being by on stage. I'm personally a fan of different High-level singers singing songs that have been sung by others, especially if the same composer /arranger is in charge.
@@TheSeeking2know This song wasn´t made for FictionJunction, was made for Kalafina. Wakana had a perfect color and texture for the harmonies in this song. Joelle has a great voice, but it just doesn't make justice to the overall powerful feeling that Magia conveys.
@@hungryghost96 Well I don't think there's a song that only one singer alone can sing on the planet. Songs were written for some people originally and others took it up afterwards. Whether in terms of covers or whatever. That's just normal.
I get goosebump when I heard the intro and when they start singing....man....how should I explain this feeling? My body is trembling in fear and I can't close my eyes at all. I just submit on my knee and watch it over and over again. What a masterpiece!
Please don't ask me how many time I watch this ever since I found this video because I have lost count lol. This is the best version! I like it so so much ❤
@@danielspitz9077 You know this. First discovered her beautiful voice on a Sound Horizon song via a RUclips recommendation. I can't recall the name right now. She was just so different from the other singers I'd been hearing. I'm glad that working with Kajiura has exposed her to a bigger audience and also taken her to the Budokan as a performer, which may not have happened otherwise. She needs to keep working with FJ and maybe she'll do some more anime tie-in leads, making her voice more memorable to anime watchers. She's had to endure a lot of comparisons to Wakana from disaffected fans, but she's weathered the storm as a professional.
@@TheSeeking2know she played Elizabeth Won Wettin in Marchen, her songs were Kono semai torikago and Haritsu no Seijo. She also sang other songs, but this is her first collaboration with Sound Horizon, which is where I discovered her as well. She has her own youtube channel and while there's not a lot of videos there, you should look it up (:
I think you're right. In the studio version Kajiura's voice was there (layered) with Keiko's for that chanting at the beginning. Wakana and Hikaru did the middle harmony, while Yuriko's voice was probably doubled for the higher harmony.
推しは推せるうちに推せ。を身をもって味わった神グループ
本当に思います。
昔、西宮にカラフィナ がショッピングモールのイベントに来ていたんです。
気になりつつも疲れてたのでスルーしてしまいました。
後でこんなに好きになるなんて思いませんもんねえ😢
@@roof_farm_hiro西宮でのイベントいきました、懐かしすぎます😢
Kalafina再結成しましたぜ。
@@スイムスイムミネラルウォーター 再結成しましたね！でも、梶浦さんが・・・😭
あれは再結成とはいわないな。
梶浦さんから手を離れた以上、ユニット名も変えるべき
武道館で この前奏流れた瞬間 会場が震えた
生でこれ聞けたのえぐかった...序盤でまどマギメドレーきて死にかけてからその後に時間ほぼ記憶ない
わーーー！鳥肌立つわー！ Hikaru のメインボーカル、KEIKOさんの衣装は、まどかみたいですー
Oh heck yeah, this IS the definitive version of Magia
Sure is. Especially live! Having Yuriko do her high harmony on stage!
Joelle does an good job singing Wakana's parts, even though she has a totally different resonance and tone.
Quattro's strings raises the level of the song above the original studio version.
@@TheSeeking2know I've said this before and I'll say it again: Kalafina songs were always meant to be performed with four people at least!
@@ryoukoizumi I totally agree 100% with you. I
@@ryoukoizumi I completely 100% agree with you. Yuki Kajiura wrote for FJ and Kalafina to have 4 voices. That's why I suspect that Maya's leaving was against Kajiura's wishes.
@@TheSeeking2know Joelle was made perfectly to sing Kalafina songs her voice goes so well with them.
Oh performing this right at the beginning of the concert was crazy I was not ready... I'm joking of course but I was surprised to hear it so soon!! Absolutely fabulous!!!
It was definitely a blood-pumping choice for the fans. One of Kajiura's darkest and most atmospheric tracks!
当日まで淡い期待はしてたんですけど…
でもやはり生で聞くのは最高でした
序盤から気持ちぶち上がりました。
Great news!
Quattro大好き
I really hope that the next madoka movie has ficionjunction for the theme song 🥲we can have a song led by keiko and maybe they can bring hikaru since she is still working with kajiura
ライブにマジで素晴らしかった演奏だ！🤩🤩
Joelle is good please dont compare her to wakana...we all know wakana voice is really rare because of it husky thats why they always fit.together with keiko..
I agree. Different voices from different singers.
Definitely a different voice but Wakana suits better the song and we're so accustomed to her voice that anyone else will sound just wrong.
@@hungryghost96 I can understand being used to a singer (in this case Wakana), but if we follow that logic then we could also say anytime FictionJunction or Kalafina covers a song by FJ Yuuka, See-Saw, or even Emily Bindiger and others it sounds "wrong".
We should be able to extend our appreciation beyond a particular singer being by on stage.
I'm personally a fan of different High-level singers singing songs that have been sung by others, especially if the same composer /arranger is in charge.
@@TheSeeking2know This song wasn´t made for FictionJunction, was made for Kalafina. Wakana had a perfect color and texture for the harmonies in this song. Joelle has a great voice, but it just doesn't make justice to the overall powerful feeling that Magia conveys.
@@hungryghost96 Well I don't think there's a song that only one singer alone can sing on the planet.
Songs were written for some people originally and others took it up afterwards. Whether in terms of covers or whatever. That's just normal.
Magia is absolute power!
このライブマジで鳥肌やったよー バンドの裏側にも席用意されてて、異常にドラムや今野さんとかに近かったんよな😊
I get goosebump when I heard the intro and when they start singing....man....how should I explain this feeling? My body is trembling in fear and I can't close my eyes at all. I just submit on my knee and watch it over and over again.
What a masterpiece!
かっこよ…
実は初めてライブでKalafinaを聴いたのがこれだったから感動して泣いてしまったのはいい思い出
🎉🎉🎉🎉
ピンク衣装素敵！
最高！👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤️✨
Joelle and Yuriko is so nice!!
Hikaru sannnnnnn, I miss your voice with Keiko and Wakanaaa 😢😢😢
Best version❤❤❤
1:27
すき！
わかなーーーーー戻ってきて〜
She's not going to give up her solo career.
はあぁぁ・・・素敵💕
"Kalafina regroups for PMMM Walpurgisnacht Rising's music" is a magical girl wish totally big enough to worth making contract with Kyubey!
Always awesome & really fit Madoka Magica 2nd arc 👍👍👍
Joelleさんとゆり姉さん…控えめに言って最高(´◉ω◉` )
Yes!🎉
そーだそーだ(๑•̀ㅁ•́๑)
マギトロぉー💕
Please don't ask me how many time I watch this ever since I found this video because I have lost count lol. This is the best version! I like it so so much ❤
"No, Madoka... Stop! Don't become a magical girl!!"
個人一番歌声かっこいい美しい曲素敵❤
I don't mean to compare, but I like this version more than the original.
You're not alone.
This is the ending of the first madoka movie so it is supposed to be a better version
You must be deaf, Wakana really suited this song much better than Joelle.
so good♥
ひかるちゃんが最初のコーラスはいるの珍しいな
I wish Kalafina can return for the next Madoka movies or at least as Fiction Junction
涙が出てきて吃驚した。kalafinaに会いたいなぁ…
I need the full version😢
i love pmmm
Joelle is wonderful in this song!
Yes she is! Giving 100%! The song demands it! It's not a gentle song.
@@TheSeeking2know yay! A fellow Joelle fan (:
@@danielspitz9077 You know this. First discovered her beautiful voice on a Sound Horizon song via a RUclips recommendation. I can't recall the name right now.
She was just so different from the other singers I'd been hearing. I'm glad that working with Kajiura has exposed her to a bigger audience and also taken her to the Budokan as a performer, which may not have happened otherwise.
She needs to keep working with FJ and maybe she'll do some more anime tie-in leads, making her voice more memorable to anime watchers.
She's had to endure a lot of comparisons to Wakana from disaffected fans, but she's weathered the storm as a professional.
We are all happy again how many year magia we did not hear @@TheSeeking2know
@@TheSeeking2know she played Elizabeth Won Wettin in Marchen, her songs were Kono semai torikago and Haritsu no Seijo.
She also sang other songs, but this is her first collaboration with Sound Horizon, which is where I discovered her as well.
She has her own youtube channel and while there's not a lot of videos there, you should look it up (:
CRYING
Mantap ❤
ひーちゃんけぇちゃん、あとはわかちゃん………😭😭😭😭
何度でも繰り返すって聞こえてきた⊂(`･ω･´)⊃ﾊﾞｯ
Is there a full version of this online some where?
Kalafina promised to come back to Mexico 😢
わかな、けいこ、ひかる、ゆきの組合せが超超超超超大好きでした。ハーモニーと辞書で調べたら"Kalafina/p梶浦由記"と書いてあるかのようなこの4人組が最高すぎた。ホントに残念で残念でなりません…(´；ω；`)
1:45 サムネ
Ya diganle a Doña Yuki que nos libere las canciones completas 😫💖
一人欠けてもこの重厚感か
❤
3人で歌ってる本家Kalafinaより歌い手の数が多い分CDに近い編成ではある
@@ぴくぴく人参 Exactly. You're right! Yuriko's doing her studio CD parts live on stage and the vocals are fuller.
なぜkalafinaは…
Kind of sad not to see Wakana there, she's incredible and irreplaceable.
When's the new Madoka sequel coming out?
Sedih banget wakananya kagak ada
2022年の1日限りのkalafinaメンバー復活ライブ思い出したよ
え!?そんなのありましたっけ？
もしあれば大事件ですよ？
ワカナがいないのがまた新鮮
大人の事情はわからんけど、あともう1人おったら復活やのになぁー
まあ仲違いでの解散だからそりゃ集まるのむずいわな
その一人がやりたくないから復活しない
リノレイアに代行してもらうのはどうか？
karafina復活！？
Berarti yuki kajiura-san sudah tidak bekerja sama dengan wakana-san ya.
Rather Wakana is not working with Yuki Kajiura.
お願いします、kalafinaを復活させて下さい！
すまん誰か教えてくれ！Kalafinaではないのは分かるんだが、ケイコさんとヒカルさんがいて…これどういう状況や？至福すぎるんだが！
去年の１２月に開催された梶浦由紀のフェス。梶浦ファミリーの歌手が集合したそうな。
貝田さんのコーラスがハマってないの初めて聞いたかもしれない。magiaにwakanaのイメージ強くはないけど、大事だったのがよく分かる。
CDのクレジット確認したけど原曲でも貝田さんコーラス入れてるよ
サビのところは単にwakanaパートのボリュームが大きいのが違和感何じゃないかな。
エエェェ〜のとこはたぶん原曲と同じコーラス割だし、違和感ない。wakanaも少し癖のある声質(歌い方？)だったからJoelleさんがサビも担当した方が違和感はなかった気もする。
私はKalafina無き今Kalafinaの歌を歌い継いでくれるだけでありがたい。
なんならイントロのコーラスは梶浦さんの声をひたすら重ねて作ってる気がしてます
Kalafinaをタブー視して封印してしまうのは悲しいですよね
I think you're right. In the studio version Kajiura's voice was there (layered) with Keiko's for that chanting at the beginning.
Wakana and Hikaru did the middle harmony, while Yuriko's voice was probably doubled for the higher harmony.
このBDは内容がいいのは言うまでもありません。しかし、制作人にはっきり言う、カメラのピントが残念なカットが多い
そう、お値段すごく高いのにアングルとか抜くタイミングが下手すぎる。今までのはこんなに酷くないんだけど。見せ場理解してなすぎるし、顔が隠れてる方からしか撮れてないとか、歌ってないパートなのに映るとか本当に良くない。綺麗な音質画質で名曲が記録されただけマシかなと思うようにしてるけど…
多数のカメラで同時に撮影している筈だから、編集の問題かな？
やはりwakanaの存在は唯一無二だったな
Kalafinaに会いたい。
マドカマギカ最高だけど会えないですヤバい地震発生戦争勃発人間駄目🥸😭🥸🥸🥸
Wakana は？
she left when Kajiura left the company back then and didn't come back
@@kuroo_nyanko 梶浦さんが会社辞めて、Wakanaは残留して辞めていないはずです。現在ソロで活動中ですよ
@@CuteBeatClub what i mean is she left Yuki Kajiura's team 😅my apologies
@@kuroo_nyanko いえいえ＾＾大丈夫です
Wakanaさんともセッションしてくれるといいですね
わーちゃん 未だスペクラの縛りがあるとは思うのですが
本当にいつか またあの声で梶浦さんのサウンド歌って欲しいです
ひどい